If you are named in a civil lawsuit in Texas, do not wait until discovery is done to file dispositive retrial motions.
Texas law and its appellate court increasingly allow defendants to attack these allegations on their face, with an eye towards quick dismissal of ‘junk lawsuits’
Kretzer & Annett used the tactic effectively in a case where Seth Kretzer was sued personally for actions her took as a court-appointed receiver.
The background was this. A Harris County judge appointed Seth Kretzer as receiver to enforce a judgment of approximately $9.9 million against World Class Capital Group, LLC and Great Value Storage, LLC. The receivership (turnover) order authorized Seth Kretzer to seize the debtors’ membership interests in their affiliated companies and to settle pending litigation. That turnover order was affirmed by the First Court of Appeals and left undisturbed by the Supreme Court of Texas. Acting under it, Mr. Kretzer took control of debtor-affiliated entities, settled their lawsuits, and satisfied the judgment in 2022.
One of those debtor-affiliated entities, WC 4th and Rio Grande, LP, then sued Mr. Kretzer personally and his law firm in Travis County, alleging that his actions exceeded his authority and were ultra vires and taken in bad faith, among other allegations. In substance, that suit sought to hold the receiver and his lawyers personally liable for carrying out the very tasks the appointing court had ordered.
Kretzer & Arnett moved to dismiss under Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 91a, specifically, ‘derived immunity’ a fact term for the fact that a court-appointed receiver acts as an arm of the court and enjoys the same absolute immunity as the appointing judge for acts within the scope of the receivership. Because every challenged action was authorized by the affirmed turnover order, the claims failed as a matter of law.
On March 5, 2026, the court granted the Rule 91a motion and dismissed all claims against Mr. Kretzer on derived immunity grounds- and his law firm on ground of ‘attorney immunity’
“Attorney immunity” is another defense well situated to 91a motions to dismiss. Recently, Texas’ Fifteenth Court of Appeals granted mandamus relief to a civil defendant who had lost his 91a motion in one of Texas’ new “Business Courts.” There, the former CEO of software company Reynolds and Reynolds could not include the company’s general counsel in a $350 million employment lawsuit, saying in a split opinion that the company’s general counsel enjoyed derived immunity. In re Frank Jackson, case number 15-25-00235-CV, in the Texas Court of Appeals for the Fifteenth District.