Understanding the appeals process can challenge even a competent attorney let alone a lay person. This overview will clarify seven key facts regarding appeals.
A Mistake during a Trial Doesn’t Mean an Automatic Appeal
Appellate court judges generally refuse to overturn lower court cases, believing that the trial judge had strong reasons for his or her ruling. The courts commonly argue that no one is guaranteed an error-free trial. The appellate court will consider a reversal only when the lower court made a ruling, such as a federal constitutional violation, that possibly affected the final outcome of the case. In other words, if the error seems relatively harmless, the appellate court will not reverse the ruling.
The Case Error Must Be Properly Documented or Preserved
When the prosecution objects to something the defense counsel presents, the judge might sustain the objection. Even if the judge should not have sided with the prosecution, your attorney might struggle to prove his or her point during an appeal. The appellate court assumes that the lower court is allowed to correct the mistake when it happens before seeking an appeal. Your defense lawyer must clearly state exactly why he or she is objecting so that the reasoning is on the record. Failure to document the error is grounds for the rejection of an appeal.
Appeals Can Be Expensive
The cost of any case, including an appeal, is directly related to its complexity and to how much time it takes. Evidence and transcripts can run upwards of thousands of pages, which take hours to read and analyze, leading to higher case fees. Some cases run into unforeseen snags, adding more work.
Every appeals case includes filing and paperwork fees, including the transcript, an appendix, and record excerpts. In some cases, technology and electronic filing might allow you to bypass some of these expenses. Additional expenses include travel and practice runs through a case. Your Houston appeals lawyer should provide you with a general idea of how much the case will cost.
Appeals Can Be Time Consuming
The time-consuming process, which can take months, adds to the expense of the case. Judges and attorneys take the time to review each and every aspect of the entire case. Nothing can speed up this process. The Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts keeps detailed data on court caseloads, which show that appeals take about a year although the range can be anywhere from nine to 17 months and longer, depending on where you live.
Most Appeals Are Settled out of Court
The U.S. Court reports that about three-fourths of cases are settled based on the brief or written document that outlines the facts of the case, the legal errors, and the specific support. The responding party counters with a similar brief. These briefs must be thoroughly researched and well written.
Request Oral Arguments
While most cases are decided out of court, some cases will be heard by a panel of appellate judges. The court might render a decision without hearing oral arguments. However, oral arguments offer another opportunity for the appellate lawyer to convince the panel to rule in your favor.
Pay Attention to Details
The appellate court has numerous technical rules that must be followed down to the letter. The court might reject a case for using the wrong color cover or incorrect font size or for missing a deadline. A seasoned attorney will handle all of these technical details in addition to submitting a strong argument in your case.
If you have any questions regarding the possible appeal of your case, call our Houston federal defense lawyer for advice. Since mounting an appeal might prove difficult, you will need federal criminal defense attorney in Houston — someone who can thoroughly review the trial record, challenge any rulings, document the related findings and argue your case as effectively as possible. Contact us today!